The European Commission is facing allegations that it sugarcoated Egypt’s social-welfare performance to justify releasing funds under a €7.4bn partnership promised by Ursula von der Leyen to President Abdel Fatah al-Sisi during her high-profile Cairo visit in 2024. The three-year “strategic and comprehensive partnership” was presented as a way to stabilise Egypt’s struggling economy, discourage migration to Europe and support a region shaken by the 7 October attacks and Israel’s war in Gaza. The controversy has also sharpened scrutiny of the EU regime’s human-rights conditions and of Egypt’s narrowing press freedoms.
Key Takeaways: The European Commission allegedly reported that Egypt had met welfare targets, helping unlock €2.5bn in soft loans, while leaked EU documents and deleted Egyptian data point to a net cut of 85,734 households. Egypt has already received €3.5bn of the €5bn macro-financial assistance package, with a final €1.5bn tranche expected before the end of 2027. EU lawmakers are now demanding clarification as the €7.4bn partnership faces questions over migration priorities, human rights and press freedom.
The dispute centres on €5bn in EU “soft” loans, known as macro-financial assistance, which is meant to be available only to countries that respect human rights and democracy. While the EU’s democracy and rights conditions are vague, the loans set more specific requirements for economic reform. The wider EU-Egypt relationship is also under scrutiny after Egyptian authorities jailed and allegedly tortured six journalists, the entire newsroom of the fact-checking platform Matsadaash, and closed one of the country’s last independent outlets last month, convicting its high-profile editor, Lina Attalah. Attalah is appealing against that conviction and is due in court this week as she seeks to overturn other charges, including “publishing false news”; she was sentenced to a year in prison in absentia without her knowledge.
Confidential EU documents, as reported, allegedly told EU lawmakers that Egypt had “broadly fulfilled” and then “fulfilled” two targets to increase the number of poor people on social-welfare programmes between 2024 and 2026. But separate data sources indicate a net reduction of 85,734 households, because the Egyptian government removed people from welfare rather than expanding coverage. Had the programmes expanded without removals, about 245,000 households — roughly 909,000 people — would be receiving benefits, according to a rough calculation using World Bank data. The leaked documents also say the Commission wanted Egypt to “further expand cash transfer programmes”; nevertheless, two soft loans totalling €2.5bn were approved. The targets relate to Takaful, which gives poor families cash on condition of health visits and school attendance, and Karama, which provides unconditional payments to people with disabilities and older people.
Dutch MEP Tineke Strik, one of the European parliament’s leading spokespeople on EU-Egypt relations, said she was introducing a question to the European Commission demanding clarification. “The finding by this investigation that the commission is seemingly sugarcoating Egypt’s performance is worrying,” she said, adding that the Commission had from the beginning used macro-financial assistance “primarily as a tool to lure Egypt into migration cooperation, while considering formal conditions and its reporting obligations towards parliament as an inconvenient formality.” Egypt has so far received €3.5bn in three instalments; the final €1.5bn is expected before the end of 2027. EU lawmakers await answers on how the welfare figures were verified and whether the funds should have been released.
Source: www.theguardian.com