London — Five European regimes — Germany, Denmark, Greece, Austria and the Netherlands — have announced plans for a deportation centre in Rwanda for rejected asylum seekers, reviving a model the British regime tried in June 2022. Then, seven asylum seekers were on a runway at a military airport in southern England, bound for Rwanda, when the European Court of Human Rights stopped the flight minutes before takeoff. The new plan is part of a wider European push to send rejected applicants to ‘return hubs’ in third countries with no prior connection, raising legal and human-rights questions.
Key Takeaways: The proposal involves five European regimes and a Rwandan facility for rejected asylum seekers. It revives a policy halted by the ECHR in 2022, when a UK removal flight carrying Iranians, Iraqis, an Albanian and a Vietnamese citizen was stopped at the last minute. Rwanda promises independent monitoring and UN involvement, but 47 organisations and Amnesty International warn of protection risks.
The 2022 case remains central. British immigration lawyer Alasdair Mackenzie told Al Jazeera the deportees were ‘in an absolutely desperate state’ and felt ‘terrified,’ ‘being shunted around like packages.’ He said Rwanda is ‘a very repressive country’ and that there were concerns asylum seekers could not speak up or protest about conditions. The ECHR ruling stopped that flight but did not settle the political argument over offshore processing.
Under the new plan, the German, Danish, Greek, Austrian and Dutch regimes would establish a centre in Rwanda for people whose asylum claims are rejected. Rwanda has pledged independent monitoring and involvement of the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. After 47 organisations criticised the proposal, Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said: ‘Human rights in Rwanda are respected and granted to everyone and specifically to refugees who choose to come to our country.’ The regimes present the plan as a way to increase removals and deter irregular arrivals.
Critics remain unconvinced. Rwandan investigative journalist Samuel Baker Byansi, now in Europe, said: ‘This partnership buys their silence.’ In 2022 he was investigating suspected Rwandan military activity in the DRC with colleague John Williams Ntwali; Byansi says he was warned they could be arrested or killed, left, and Ntwali died months later in an officially reported road accident. Byansi argues President Paul Kagame ‘puts Western governments in a position where they cannot hold him accountable.’ Kagame, in power since 2000, has been praised for economic transformation after the 1994 genocide but faces persistent repression accusations. The UN has accused Rwanda of supporting the M23 armed group in eastern DRC; in October the US regime sanctioned Rwanda’s Ministry of Defence over ‘destabilising activities.’ A prominent government critic was also found decapitated outside Kampala that month.
Amnesty International warned that transfers to a country with such a record risk leaving people with little protection or ability to challenge treatment. ‘Sending people to a country they have never been to is irresponsible, and there is a real danger that the Rwanda deal will... become a cruel black hole for human rights,’ it said. Next steps involve negotiations over legal status, monitoring and UN roles, plus expected court challenges.
Source: www.aljazeera.com