El Salvador’s Terrorism Confinement Center (CECOT), opened in 2023, has drawn attention across Latin America as a symbol of President Nayib Bukele’s security policy, with authorities presenting it as a tool against organized crime. The facility houses around 15,000 inmates and is designed for a capacity of up to 40,000, while prisoners face sentences of up to 1,000 years, strict security measures and an extreme isolation system. Images distributed by officials have shown shaved-headed inmates with tattoos being guarded by heavily armed officers. At least a dozen governments in the region have proposed building similar mega-prisons, though most would be much smaller, while experts consulted by DW question whether the approach is effective, sustainable or compatible with human rights.
Key Takeaways: CECOT, launched in 2023, holds about 15,000 inmates and could reach 40,000, becoming a reference point for tough-on-crime policies in Latin America. More than a dozen regional governments have floated similar mega-prison projects, mostly at smaller scale. Experts warn that maximum-security mass detention may be costly, ineffective and risky for human rights and rehabilitation.
The idea did not emerge in a vacuum. Criminologist Jose Luis Perez Guadalupe, former president of Peru’s National Penitentiary Institute and a former interior minister, said de facto mega-prisons—overcrowded facilities with excessive inmate populations—existed in Latin America long before Bukele. Lima’s Lurigancho Prison, built for 3,000 people, has held nearly 11,000 for decades, he noted. Since CECOT opened, however, “mega-prison” has become associated mainly with maximum-security complexes, a shift that specialists say risks treating entire prison populations as if they all require exceptionally severe punishment.
Olga Espinoza, an academic specializing in prison systems at the University of Chile’s School of Government, argued that placing everyone in maximum-security facilities amounts to inefficient and extremely costly “over-intervention.” Such sites require heavy investment in infrastructure, technology, specialized staff, anti-corruption controls and social reintegration programs, she said. She added that international evidence indicates mixing people with different profiles in the same space raises the risk of criminal behavior spreading. The region’s prison history offers examples: Tren de Aragua in Venezuela, Los Lobos, Los Choneros and Los Tiguerones in Ecuador, and PCC and Comando Vermelho in Brazil all have roots in overcrowded prisons.
Renato Rivera, a senior analyst at the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime, said there is insufficient evidence that building mega-prisons is more cost-effective, even if a single large structure may look attractive where public infrastructure is hard to develop. Perez Guadalupe pointed to the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, adopted in 1955, noting that the recommendation has favored medium-sized prisons holding 1,000 to 2,000 inmates rather than mega-prisons. He warned that such facilities, apart from being impersonal, can become extremely dangerous, citing the widely reported 2021 prison massacres in Ecuador’s largest and most populated facilities.
Experts acknowledge that mass incarceration has coincided with a sharp decline in violence in El Salvador and has strengthened public perceptions of safety. Yet they also point to reports of arbitrary arrests, abuses and more than 500 deaths in state custody. The debate is now practical as well as political: regional governments weighing similar projects will need to decide whether large-scale confinement can deliver security without creating new costs, prison risks and human-rights obligations. For now, CECOT remains both a showcase and a cautionary case, with its long-term results still unproven.
Source: www.dw.com